I noticed that I had a blog post in draft form from the summer. Do you do this as a blogger? I’m not sure why I didn’t post it then; maybe it didn’t feel complete or I wasn’t happy with it. Nonetheless, I pushed myself way too hard yesterday and have to be gentle with myself, so this is my 3/10 post.
When I was researching for my Social Media in Education course, I put out an informal survey on Twitter. It was by no means a scientific survey: I didn’t have a control group and the fact is, because I used Twitter to administer the survey, many of the kids who responded had teachers who already use social media in their classrooms. So though so this is not hard data by any means, it is interesting.
The respondents were from grade 6-8 (so ages 11-14 years old) and this what they said when I asked whether or not social media should be used in school:
And here’s the interesting thing I noticed when students responded to the question, “Why” or “Why not”. Students who had used social media in their classroom for the purposes of learning (three times or more) had a positive attitude towards the potential of social media verses the students who never did.
Look at these extremes:
Here are the responses from kids who said yes. Most of these students had indicated that they had had the opportunity to use social media in their classes:
- because it is a good way to share how you are learning with people around the world
- because you will learn about thing all the time and the world is coming to the point where you will need to use social media
- because it can be educational and fun.
- because it helps with learning and it gives us an experience.
- Yes, because it is a great resource for learning, if you go on certain accounts, it can actually help you learn something, all the major companies use social media.
- it can help you get comfortable with talking to people
And there was a group of students who did not actually use social media in school, but indicated that wished they could be:
- some social media can help you learn about whats going on in the world right now. Also, some kids enjoy using social media, so maybe kids would be more interested in learning if they could use social media to learn and connect with and about the world
- I think it should because it could potentially be a resource, and it could help with the understanding of the online life
- Social media should be used in school as it helps children learn something that they are used to using. Today, almost all children use social media.
There were many students (32 out of 102 respondents) who were not sure, but could not exactly articulate why. There were many, “I don’t know” responses and “I’m not sure” and one student articulated it this way: I’m not sure because I don’t really understand how using social media would help students learn in class.
Of the students who said no (13 out of 102 respondents) to using social media in school, it seemed to focus on hypotheticals and the fear narrative:
- Because too much social media is bad and could strain our eyes if we’re on it to long.
- If students were allowed to use social media at school today it would have been a problem because there could be a cyberbully.
- We shouldn’t because the kids might not be using it appropriately
What stood out most to me from the survey results was the stark difference between the attitudes of the students who used social media daily and were given the opportunity to use social media in the classroom more than 5 times in a school year, versus what students who use social media daily, but who had never been given the opportunity to use it in class had to say. You see, those students only look that their own social use, their tendency to be distracted by their friends’ posts. They are also likely the students who have been taught nothing about social media beyond how bad it is, so it is no wonder that they could not see any educational value.
And yet, I continue to talk to teachers from across the globe who cannot use social media in their classrooms because it is blocked or banned.
Do we invite students to District-level tables? Do we have a student school advisory team at the school level?
Will anything ever change if we don’t change the path we are currently taking when it comes to using social media in the classroom?
Here is the summary of responses if you are interested.